TanToday - Helping Salon Owners, One At A Time, Since 2000! - View Single Post

JeffK · 16th June 2008, 05:03 PM

Since it seems moot to have Din try to make one for you, I will chime in and then register a vote.

Had it not been winning by such a wide margin I never would have said this, but design #2 is absolutely positively hideous. From the font choice to the way .com is positioned to the wave, to the colours... It's truly horrible for a logo..

#1 and #3 are good, but the . in .com should be round, not square.. it doesn't fit in with all the other letters, which are roundish where possible.

Colour scheme, having the two different colours on the T's in TanToday looks bad in design #3, then having .com in grey doesn't fit.. so I'm going with design #1..

I would choose #1 over Din's also because while the sun is nice, logos nowadays are going back to being simplistic when possible.. but if Din did that in a few minutes as just a pure response, with no time to prepare or think about a plan for the logo then you would be remiss in not offering him the chance at atleast trying.. plus you'd win support of the readership.. never hurts..

16th June 2008, 05:03 PM	#26 (permalink)
JeffK Super Star Join Date: Aug 2007 Location: USA Posts: 615	Re: VOTE: New TanToday Logo Since it seems moot to have Din try to make one for you, I will chime in and then register a vote. Had it not been winning by such a wide margin I never would have said this, but design #2 is absolutely positively hideous. From the font choice to the way .com is positioned to the wave, to the colours... It's truly horrible for a logo.. #1 and #3 are good, but the . in .com should be round, not square.. it doesn't fit in with all the other letters, which are roundish where possible. Colour scheme, having the two different colours on the T's in TanToday looks bad in design #3, then having .com in grey doesn't fit.. so I'm going with design #1.. I would choose #1 over Din's also because while the sun is nice, logos nowadays are going back to being simplistic when possible.. but if Din did that in a few minutes as just a pure response, with no time to prepare or think about a plan for the logo then you would be remiss in not offering him the chance at atleast trying.. plus you'd win support of the readership.. never hurts..