Quote:
Originally Posted by Ezliving_Jim  My opinion: all 3 designs are weak. The "The #1...." slogan is even weaker and has no place in the logo. The font in design #2 is better than the other's because of the forum's focus on news, opinions, typed communications. Instead of the "The #1..." slogan, consider something like: "A Community Of Indoor Tanning Industry Professionals" Did you notice the link to the Cluetrain Manifesto? That's just the beginning. There is a book behind it. The Cluetrain Manifesto — Entire Text Index Page Ignore it at one's own peril. |
Absolutely!
I didn't vote, because a logo for a website is of no importance or relevance to me.
That said - I immediately was turned off by the "tag line"!
Agree with the "#1" being unnecessary (earn it, don't say it) and think "salon owners" is untrue, limited, and short sighted.
The Original TanToday WAS the premier place for ALL the professionals in the industry to gather. For a lot of reasons, I don't see that ever happening again. However, if that is the goal to move toward that direction, these wouldn't be the "logos" I would pick.
But it's not my site, I'm not a graphics person, and I will come or not come regardless of what logo and tag line is picked.